Wednesday, March 31, 2010

The Postmistress

I had high hopes for this book, The Postmistress by Sarah Blake.  My favorite time historical time period is the World War II years, so naturally this novel seemed to be a perfect fit.  Unfortunately, I feel the story falls short of the author's attempt at weaving two worlds together. 

The story begins at a dinner party where a guest recalls a time when a postal worker withholds the mail and the chain reaction that this causes.  However, the exposition before this event occurs is nearly the entire book!  While the exposition and rising action of the novel kept me somewhat involved, I wasn't truly invested in the story.  I kept waiting for the postal worker's huge indiscretion to occur.  While the story was over developed,characters didn't seem to be developed enough for me to be truly invested in them.  When happiness or tragedy occurred within the novel I really didn't feel much of anything for them. 

I did enjoy Frankie Bard's story and believe that this would lead to a much stronger and more intriguing plot.  Her story, and the stories of other reporters during wartime in London, would have been a much better use of the author's time and energy.  I found myself counting the pages until the end of the book.

Sunday, March 28, 2010

Sunrise over Fallujah

Walter Dean Myers' novel Sunrise over Fallujah explained the war against Iraq to me better than any news' story.  Myers' conveys the absolute confusion over just who is the enemy.  Sunrise over Fallujah follows Robin, Ritchie's (the main character in Fallen Angels) nephew during his tour of duty in Iraq. 

Throughout the novel we follow Robin, or Birdy as he is called by his fellow soldiers, as his view on the war changes.  Robin enlists because of 9/11.  He feels the need to "do something".  However, after Robin arrives in Iraq his feeling begin to change.  The sadness and frustration he feels is evident.  Myers' has a distinct ability to describe the action and the character's feelings without making anything seem exaggerated. 

I enjoyed this novel far more than I thought I would.  Sunrise gave me a better understanding of just what the United States is doing in Iraq.  In addition, the story let me into the hearts and minds of soldiers.  Myers' story left me with the impression that there is no easy explanation for war or just who the enemy is.

Saturday, March 27, 2010

Stuck in Neutral

Terry Trueman's Stuck in Neutral is an immensely powerful book packed into less than 120 pages.  Shawn McDaniel's is a teen-age boy who has cerebral palsy.   With an IQ estimated at 1.2 (equivalent to a mental age of 3-4 months), Shawn has been called a "vegetable" or "retard".  But, what nobody knows is that inside himself, Shawn is a genius. 

Shawn remembers everything he has ever heard or seen since he was 3 or 4 years old.  He learned to read because his older sister used to play teacher.  Shawn was the student.  But, because he has no muscle control whatsoever, he cannot communicate at all.  He cannot voluntarily blink or grunt.  He blames himself for his father's fame and his parent's divorce.  His father is a Pulitzer Prize winning poet; the subject of the winning poem - Shawn. 

The current topic of Sydney's (Shawn's father) writing is the story of Earl Detraux, a man who murdered his two year old son.  Earl killed his boy, Colin, because he, like Shawn, would only live a life in misery and suffering.  And, now Shawn, fears that he may suffer the same fate as little Colin. 

Trueman's story becomes even more powerful when you read the afterword.  His son Sheehan has cerebral palsy, just like Shawn.  As a parent I know that there is no job more challenging and I live for the smiles, the hugs and cuddles I receive as payment from my beautiful daughter.   I can only imagine raising a child like Shawn or Sheehan.  The rewards would be few and far between.  Stuck in Neutral is a compelling story of the "what ifs".

River of Words: The Story of William Carlos Williams

I was drawn to this book not only because it would be a resource for my Language Arts class, but also because of the unique illustrations.  The book will be a wonderful introduction to the poet William Carlos Williams.  Jen Bryant has written a concise and clever biography of one of my favorite poets.  Willie, as she called him in her book, was always interested in poetry; however, he chose to become a doctor because he knew poetry wouldn't pay the bills. 

I love that he continued to write despite the fact poetry wasn't lucrative.  Following one's passion is an important lesson for young people.  Money, while important, certainly isn't everything!

Melissa Sweet's illustrations, created as paintings on pages and covers of discarded books, are gorgeous.  Within her illustrations one finds Williams's words.  There is so much to observe and learn on each page.  I've read the book several times and still find something new to look at on each page.

I'm looking forward to sharing this book with my students!  I hope that they will enjoy William Carlos Williams's poetry as much as I do!

Friday, March 26, 2010

Briar Rose

Briar Rose is a Holocaust story, but it is so much more.  Becca's grandmother, Gemma, tells her granddaughters the story of Briar Rose.  Briar Rose's tale is much like Sleeping Beauty's, only more haunting.  On her deathbed, Gemma reveals that she is Briar Rose.  Becca promises her grandmother that she will solve the mystery that is her life.

What follows is Becca's journey to discover the story of Gemma's life.  Jane Yolen has crafted a beautiful story that also reveals some of history's most horrifying moments.  What I most enjoyed about Yolen's tale is that she has chosen to incorporate the punishments taken on homosexuals, a topic that is rarely seen in literature about the Holocaust. 

This fictional story is geared toward older, more mature readers.  Not only because of the frank discussion of homosexuality, but also because of the vivid descriptions of the killing fields of Chelmno.  I have read many, many true and fictional accounts of the Holocaust.   Briar Rose is one of the most beautiful stories I have read about the atrocities of the Holocaust.

Monday, March 22, 2010

Heavy Words Lightly Thrown: The Reason Behind the Rhyme

I love the etymology of words.  When I came across the book Heavy Words Lightly Thrown:  The Reason Behind the Rhyme by Chris Roberts I became very excited.  A book that explains the meanings of nursery rhymes -- awesome!  The concept of this book, especially as a new parent, is totally spot on. However, as I should have considered, the explanations might contain a bit of drudgery.

Thankfully, Roberts writing style emulates that of many of my favorite British comedians:  John Clease and anyone from Monty Python's Flying Circus immediately come to mind!  Roberts is sneaky.  The humor is subtle and you have to read everything he's written because otherwise you might miss some hidden jocular gem.

The glossary he added to the American edition was immensely helpful.  Not quite the Anglophile I thought I was, I consulted the glossary almost every instance an asterisk popped up.  I was also intrigued by the concept of "rhyming slang" and spent considerable time trying to completely understand it.  Although my inability to fully grasp the intricacies of this Cockney slang completely explain my lack of understanding for the movies Lock, Stock, and Two Smoking Barrels or Snatch!

Sunday, March 21, 2010

Fallen Angels

Fallen Angels, by Walter Dean Myers, is a title that has been taught at my school off and on.  I have never read the novel, and figured it was high time I did so.  Taking place during the Vietnam War, Myers tells the story of Ritchie Perry and his fellow soldiers Peewee, Lobel, Johnson and Brunner.

Perry is just 17 and has graduated from high school.  He enlists as he knows that there is no money for college and life in Brooklyn has gotten to be too challenging.  Perry is swiftly sent off to Vietnam.  We follow him through night duty, reconnaissance and battle and the drudgery of war.  There seems to be a lot of sitting around and waiting.  Myers's descriptions don't leave much to the imagination, although none of it is too gory.  The language used in the story is fitting for young soldiers, but may be a bit much for some middle school students for whom this book is targeted.

This novel would be an excellent novel for students to read prior to reading Shooting the Moon.  A study could be made comparing the soldiers and those they leave behind.   I am looking forward to reading Myer's Sunrise over Fallujah as it's a follow-up of sorts; the main character is Perry's nephew. 

 

Anne Frank: The Book, The Life, The Afterlife

As a teen, like so many others, I was introduced to The Holocaust through Anne's diary.  Francine Prose's Anne Frank:  The Book, The Life, The Afterlife introduced me to an entirely different Anne.  Anne, the author. 

Through Prose's work I discovered new facts.  For instance, Anne rewrote parts of her diary in the months before she and her fellow annex-mates were captured.  Spurred by directive of the Dutch government that memories of this awful time should be documented, Anne begins to rewrite parts of her diary.  I was amazed to see her transformation as a writer... as the author she always wanted to be.

Interesting, too, were the many lawsuits surrounding the penning of a stage play and a movie.  The politics surrounding this endeavor were shocking to me.  The facts that the play came across as too sad, too Jewish or too depressing are so funny to me.  By definition, that is what The Holocaust is.  But, sad, depressing and Jewish apparently wouldn't sell.  Coupled with the issues of making Anne's diary universally appealing were the claims that her whole diary was just created by money-hungry Jews. 

Unfortunately the claims by Holocaust deniers that the diary was fiction, were not surprising to me.  One would think that the mountains of evidence to support the annihilation of 6 million Jews and millions of others would be enough.  It's amazing how facts can be twisted to support anyone's insane view of history. 

Anne Frank:  The Book, The Life, The Afterlife is a beautiful tribute to an amazing young girl.  Prose's book gave me the opportunity to learn even more about Anne and her truly amazing ability to convey a story.

Saturday, March 20, 2010

Getting Stoned with Savages: A Trip Through the Islands of Fiji and Vanuatu

My husband, Daniel, and I have always joked about quitting our jobs and moving to a tropical island.  He'd mix coconut drinks on the beach and I would braid hair.  After reading Getting Stoned with Savages by J. Maarten Troost, I've decided paradise may not be all it's hyped up to be.   This is the second book by Troost.  In his first book, Sex Lives of Cannibals, he writes about his adventures on the island of Kiribati.  In both books it is his wife's job that takes them to the far away Oceanic Islands.

Getting Stoned with Savages takes Troost and his wife to the Islands of Fiji and Vanuatu.  While one often reads of lush celebrity vacations in Fiji, this is not the Fiji where Troost lives.  Troost's Fiji is filled with giant centipedes, corrupt government and the intoxicating drink, kava.  His adventure begins in Vanuatu, a somewhat rural island, but compared to his first adventure in Kiribati, it's incredibly civilized.  On Vanuatu he is introduced to kava.  A drink with narcotic properties.  Kava begins as a root which is chewed by children.  The saliva and masticated root are spit into a bucket.  And, that finished product is kava.  When drunk, the high is very much like smoking weed, only better, according to Troost.

The book is a journal of his family's time on the islands.  Troost's writing style is full of sarcasm and dry humor.  His books are enjoyable, quick reads, although not quite a marketing tool for the islands he has visited.  Troost's latest book, Lost on Planet China:  One Man's Attempt to Understand the World's Most Mystifying Nation, looks to be as entertaining as his first two.  Although I've always wanted to visit China...  maybe I should skip his book!

  

Thursday, March 18, 2010

March Toward the Thunder

I will readily admit that The Civil War is not my favorite time period in history.  However, after having created a thorough unit on The Holocaust teaching solely through literature, I came to realize how much more interested my students were about learning about historical events.  To that end, I am in the process of creating a literature unit for early American History.  March Toward The Thunder is a story about The Civil War from a Canadian Indian boy's point of view.

Louis is barely 15, but he looks far older.  A member of the Abenaki tribe, he works with his mother selling hand-made baskets.  He is approached by an army recruiter and convinced to join up.  This is how Louis's army career begins.  He is a member of the 69th Irish Brigade.  At first he meets with a bit of resistance and teasing from his fellow soldiers; however, once others realize that he won't be bothered by their ribbing, he is accepted.

The story follows the brigade for no more than six months, although through Louis's eyes the battles seem to go on for so much longer.  Famous places like Andersonville are mentioned, as are famous people:  General Lee, General Grant, President Lincoln and even the famous poet Walt Whitman.  Author Joseph Bruchac carefully and extensively researched every aspect of his novel.  He stated that although Louis is not a real character (although based a bit on his great grandfather), every character is rooted in factual information.

While the book dragged for me at times, there were enough surprises to keep me reading.  I obviously won't divulge them, but Bruchac definitely has an art for keeping a reader on her toes!  This book would be an interesting addition to my early American history unit for many reasons.  I like the fact that there is information regarding the Colored Divisions of the northern army, as well as the fact that Louis is a Native American character.  The fact that Native Americans and African-Americans served in the Civil War may be new to many of my students and this novel introduces their stories quite well.  Overall, March Toward the Thunder will provide a great introduction to The War Between the States.

Snow Flower and the Secret Fan

Stories of strong women are compelling to me.  Stories of life-long friendship are also appealing.  Lisa See's Snow Flower and the Secret Fan has both.  The story takes place in 19th century China.  A time when a woman's job is to get married, take care of her husband and his family and bear sons.  It's also a time when a woman is judged almost solely on the size of her feet.  The horribly cruel practice of foot binding figures prominently in this story.

Lily and Snow Flower become "laotong" or "old sames".  This is a match, similar to a marriage, but it's between women.  It's an emotional relationship designed to provide women a friendship that will last through the different phases of their lives.  This match began at age seven and carried them through death.  Although often separated by distance the two communicate through "nu shu", a secret language created by women.  Through this language women write to each other on fans, handkerchiefs and other pieces of cloth covertly sharing significant parts of their lives.

Lisa See has crafted a beautiful story of women and their lives.  For me, this story was reminiscent of The Red Tent because of its careful attention to the lives and traditions of womanhood.  At times I felt fairly voyeuristic as I observed the women at their most intimate moments.  My heart broke for Lily and Snow Flower at just how little joy was a part of their lives.  Births and marriages were quite sorrowful events if just the right combination of circumstances did not occur.  See's descriptive language took my to the far away and foreign land of rural China.  

Wednesday, March 17, 2010

Shooting the Moon

The Vietnam War in the mind of today's middle school student is ancient history.  Frances O'Roark Dowell's Shooting the Moon makes the "ancient history" much more understandable and accessible for students.  The themes of honor, duty and country resonate strongly in this story of the Dexter family.

The Dexters are an Army family.  Their father is a Colonel, who followed in the military footsteps of his father.  Jamie's 18 year old brother, TJ, enlists in the Army Medical Corp against the wishes of his parents.  Jamie is more than proud of her brother and is confused by her parent's lack of enthusiasm when TJ shares his plans.  TJ is sent to Vietnam shortly after he finishes basic training.  Jamie looks forward to his descriptions of  real-life combat.  However, what she receives is far different from her expectations.


TJ sends his parents letters; he sends Jamie rolls of film.  The scenes of life in Vietnam reveal a much more scary side of war, images that Jamie doesn't even share with her parents.  The more she sees the more she questions the honor and duty of serving in a war for one's country.  Jamie's ideas and ideals evolve and change as she learns about war through her brother's lens.

Shooting the Moon is an excellent story that will encourage children to think of the price soldiers pay to serve and protect us.  While the story takes place during the late 1960s, early 1970s it could easily take place during any war, as the historical aspects do not overwhelm the story.  However, the story could also be an extremely basic introduction to the Vietnam War, at least familiarizing the students with the event.

Tuesday, March 16, 2010

Finally

It may come as no surprise to most people, but I was an awkward pre-teen.  I always believed that once I became a teen that gawkiness would magically disappear and I would become the belle of the ball.  Unlike Cinderella that didn't happen, but it was my faith in milestones that kept me going.  Wendy Mass's novel Finally is about reaching milestones, making wishes and believing in who you are -- even if you don't recognize yourself at that moment in time!

Rory Swenson is hours away from turning 12.  She has compiled a list of things she'll be able to do once she reaches the magical age:  own a cell phone, stay home alone, own a pet, get her ears pierced, attend a boy-girl party, be a baby-sitter, watch Friday the Thirteenth IX and a few other things that are almost as important.  Rory's life is about to get much more exciting.

Not only is Rory turning 12, but her school just happens to be the set location of a new teen movie starring teen heartthrob, Jake Harrison.  Rory begins to check off items from her "When I'm Finally Twelve" list, and the results of each completed task aren't always what she has expected.  However, each passing task leads her closer and closer to what she needs.

I enjoyed the realistic characters, teenager and adult, created by Mass.  Their conversations were identifiable and not reaching for slang or trying to be overly hip.  The story very much taught a lesson, but wasn't over-bearing or preachy.  Through a clever set of coincidences, Wendy Mass shows the reader that sometimes what we think we want is not what we know we need deep down inside.  I will definitely be reading more of this author's books and recommending them to my students!

Out of My Mind

No one wants to be different, especially children on the brink of adolescence. Learning to be accepting of people for who they are and not judging someone by appearance alone is not something everyone does readily.  Unfortunately, tweens and teens seem to have the most difficult time accepting those who are different.  Sharon M. Draper's story Out of My Mind is Melody's story, in her own words.  Although, she has never spoken at all.

Melody has "spastic bilateral quadriplegia, also known as cerebral palsy.  It limits my body, but not my mind."  Trapped within her own mind we follow Melody as she navigates through the fifth grade.  For the first time in all of her school years, Melody has a teacher who believes in inclusion, rather than just playing nursery rhymes and reviewing letters.  For Melody this is an incredible opportunity because hidden inside a body that cannot move on its own, is a brain busting with knowledge.

Life changes drastically for Melody with the inclusion program.  First, she is given an aide, Catherine.  With Catherine's help her inclusion expands from just Music to Language Arts and Science.  A bigger change occurs when she receives her Medi-Talker, a device that allows her to speak pre-programmed words and phrases with the touch of a finger.  For the first time, Melody is able to speak her mind using much more than just "yes" or "no".    This new device makes it possible for Melody to participate in class.  Teachers and students are realizing that there is much more to Melody.  This becomes very evident when she is the first student in the history of Mr. Dimming's coaching the Whiz Kids competition to receive a perfect score on the preliminary test earning her a place on the school's team.

As a parent, this book made my heart break and rejoice.  I wanted so badly to rescue Melody from the painful incidents and celebrate her victories.  As a teacher, I realized that sometimes, like a few of the people in the novel, I have not served the needs of my students as well as I could or should have.  As a teacher it is my job to protect and enrich the minds of my students, regardless of their current abilities or potential.  This story is a good reminder that ALL students have potential, sometimes they just can't show you without assistance.

 Draper has written a beautiful story of a girl who just wants to be normal.  This is a story and a character I won't forget.

The House on Mango Street

The House on Mango Street seems to be a component of many high school curriculum.  Of course the novel, being relatively new when I was in high school, was not a part of my required reading.  I am so glad I finally sat down and read this book.

The vignettes are so incredibly powerful.  Autobiographical in nature Sandra Cisneros tells the story of Esperanza Cordero, a young Latina girl growing up in Chicago.  We read of her dreams, hopes, aspirations and reality.  Cisneros is able to convey powerfully complex messages in simple, easy-to-reach language.  Her introduction to the 25th Anniversary edition she says, "... people who are busy working for a living deserve beautiful little stories, because they don't have much time and are often tired."  Her goal to touch the every day reader is definitely realized.

As an educator, I can definitely see the appeal of teaching this text.  There is such beautiful, rich language.  The stories are heart-wrenching, humorous and novel.  However, I can also see where the teaching of this collection of touching vignettes could be absolutely destroyed through over-teaching and analyzing.

As Billy Collins, US Poet Laureate from 2001 to 2003 said in his poem, "An Introduction to Poetry":

But all they want to do
is tie the poem to a chair with rope
and torture a confession out of it.

I can see thousands of teachers ruining The House on Mango Street for hundreds, maybe thousands, of students...

This is one novel that should just be savored, not tortured.

Monday, March 15, 2010

The Mysterious Benedict Society and the Perilous Journey

Trenton Lee Stewart did it again!  The second adventure of The Mysterious Benedict Society is just as clever and fun as the first!  In fact, I would say I enjoyed the adventure a bit more, especially since I had a better understanding of Nicholas Benedict and his clever clues.

This adventure starts off as a reunion of sorts for the four child prodigies:  Reynie, Sticky, Kate and Constance.  However, what had originally been intended on a vacation with a challenging twist, turned into a life-saving mission for the man that brought the four children together.

I truly enjoyed Stewart's further development and exploration of the children's personalities and talents.  I felt as though I were watching the four adventurers grow up and discover themselves.  Quarrels and squabbles occur between the four of them that make the dynamics of their friendship all the more realistic.  Much like siblings, the four truly care about each other, but sometimes their strong-willed temperaments win out over affection.

As an adult, my only complaint, is that I sometimes (okay, most of the time) can't figure out the puzzles until the character explains his or her thought process to the rest of the group.  While I find this fact extremely frustrating -- because I'm a grown up ;o) -- Stewart has taken care of this potential issue for more youthful readers.  Through the voice of Mr. Benedict, he lets the characters (and the reader) know that we all have special talents.  It is through working together that everyone's talents are celebrated and the importance of those talents recognized.

Sunday, March 14, 2010

Kiss My Math: Showing Pre-Algebra Who's Boss

A friend had lent me this book, Kiss My Math:  Showing Pre-Algebra Who's Boss, a long time ago... I sat down and finally perused it today.  There are so many positive reasons to buy this book:  Danica McKellar (Winnie on The Wonder Years) is the author, she has a math degree, AND she tells it like it is!

I loved the character of Winnie on The Wonder Years.  She was nerdy, smart and the kind of kid I thought I was.  It seems to me Danica is similar in a lot of ways to her character.  Not so much nerdy, but she's definitely smart.  The way her book is written is very reflective of how I teach and interact with students.  I truly love her message to young ladies:  IT'S OKAY TO BE SMART AND SHOW IT!

Integrated within the awesome math advice is even more awesome life advice:  how to talk to teachers, managing stress, choosing friends wisely.  This book is so much more than a math aid... it's a life aid.  This is a book I will not only be recommending to my students, but also insisting my daughter reads it.  Well, when she can read, and is in Algebra!

The Book of One Hundred Truths

In the story The Book of One Hundred Truths by Jule Schumacher, we meet Theodora Grumman (Thea) and learn she is a self-proclaimed liar.  Sent to the Jersey Shore for an annual visit with her grandparents, her mother has asked her to record 100 truths in a blue notebook.  Secrets and lies are the main theme of this book.  And, it is through the lies and secrets, that Thea learns the truth about herself.


This book isn't the most earth-shattering young adult novel I've read.  While the build up to the secrets and lies is big, once revealed they just aren't that compelling.  What is disappointing is that the secrets the Grumman family is keeping and the lies Thea tells to protect her secret have the potential to be much more heart-wrenching and life-changing.  However, Schumacher doesn't take the story far enough.

Knowing my students and their hate of endings that do not sum everything up and provide a tidy package of an ending, this book would not be one of their favorites.  However, I think that young adults would like to read about the relationship between Thea and Jocelyn because everyone can relate to that pesky younger sibling, cousin or neighbor!

Ruined: A Novel

Ruined by Paula Morris was highlighted during my school's Scholastic book fair.  Taking place in New Orleans a few years after Hurricane Katrina, Ruined follows New Yorker, Rebecca, as she moves in with her "Aunt".  Sent to a ritzy all-girls' school where she is clearly out-classed, Rebecca finds it difficult to make friends.  She befriends Lisette; however, she has been dead for 155 years!  The only other person to reach out to Rebecca is Anton.  Her "Aunt" has warned her to stay away from Anton. 

For the fourth quarter my students will be reading a fantasy or science fiction novel for their independent project.  With voodoo, ghosts and teenage romance, Ruined contains enough elements of fantasy to satisfy the project requirements.  Not only will students enjoy Rebecca's story, but also will be effortlessly learning a bit of New Orleans' history and culture. 

Not being a fan of romance stories, especially teen-age romance stories, I had my doubts about Morris's novel, especially after Anton was introduced.  But, the romance is sweet, definitely not sappy and overbearing.  In fact, I found myself wanting to read more about Rebecca and Anton. 

Ruined is a quick, but enjoyable read.  I'm looking forward to hearing my students' opinions on the story and seeing their creative projects. 

Saturday, March 13, 2010

13 Little Blue Envelopes

One of the greatest gifts I receive as a teacher is being educated by my students.  At the end of third quarter, each of my students gave a book talk of their independent reading novel.  Elizabeth shared the story of 13 Little Blue Envelopes.  I was so intrigued by the story, I asked to borrow the book.  I'm glad I did!  It was a very easy and quite enjoyable read.

The story is simple.  Ginny's aunt has died and given her $1000 and the instructions to get a passport and buy a plane ticket to New York.  Sent to their favorite greasy-spoon Chinese restaurant, Ginny receives a large envelope full of tiny blue envelopes.   Each envelope contains instructions to an adventure.

Each adventure sends Ginny across Europe.  Along the way she meets a variety of people each connected to her aunt's life in some way:  Richard, Mari -- the artist, Ortensia the Italian inn keeper, Piet, a guard at a Copenhagen museum.  Along the way Ginny learns about her elusive aunt, but more importantly, about herself.

This novel is a wonderful mixture of a coming-of-age story, teenage romance and adventure.  Definitely a fun read!

The Story of Edgar Sawtelle: A Novel

I picked up The Story of Edgar Sawtelle not really knowing anything about it.  After reading the book jacket I was intrigued with the idea of a boy who could not speak, but could hear.  That is where my fascination with this novel ended.  The story, while interesting, seemed to move too slowly to truly keep my attention.  I also had a challenging time keeping details straight.  Normally this isn't an issue for me.  I had to reread sections several times to understand them.  In more than one instance, I never did grasp the section I reread.

Comparisons of this novel to Hamlet have been made.  I will readily admit that my recollection of Shakespeare's tragedy is rusty, at best.  This comparison especially confused me in light of the character of Ida Paine.  Creepy soothsayers can be found in MacBeth, not Hamlet.  In any case, I won't make a list of comparisons between Wroblewski's work and Shakespeare's.  But, it should be noted that the author himself readily admits the similarities.

Not being a dog person, I wasn't entirely drawn into the story as I would imagine someone with a love and passion for dogs would be.  However, the concept of how and why certain dogs are mated and how certain traits are encouraged was fascinating.  Overall, I wish more had been told just how Edgar was able to train the dogs despite his language limitations.  I really don't think the author did this aspect justice.

Overall, The Story of Edgar Sawtelle, was an intriguing read, but not one that I would want to revisit again... unlike the many ghosts that revisit Edgar.

Monday, March 8, 2010

The Sunflower

Simon Wiesenthal may be best known for his dedication to hunting Nazi war criminals and bringing them to justice.  However his book, The Sunflower, provides the world with an equally valuable service, to question oneself and our actions.  The Sunflower is written in two parts.  The first part tells of his encounter with a dying SS soldier while he was incarcerated in a work camp .  The dying man asks for Wiesenthal's forgiveness as a representative of the Jewish community the soldier has persecuted and murdered.  Simon leaves the room without saying a word.

The question of granting this forgiveness has troubled Wiesenthal, so much so that he has written fifty-three men and women to determine whether his decision to not respond to the dying SS man was the right thing?  The responses of the Holocaust survivors, survivors of more recent genocides, theologians, human rights activists and others comprise the second part of this fascinating book.  Their responses make me question what I would have done and my thoughts on the concept of forgiveness, retribution and compassion.

This book provides the opportunity to really look at one's self internally.  I found myself not only pondering Wiesenthal's question, but also thinking about other situations where a decision to forgive was necessary.  Although there is no way to determine definitively what the correct answer is, if there even is a correct answer, I found that the exercise in thinking and reflecting to be an extremely worthwhile experience.  I hope to use passages from The Sunflower in my classroom and look forward to the conversations the book will produce.

Sunday, March 7, 2010

Love that Dog and Hate That Cat

Every Fourth Quarter of the school year, I teach poetry.  I find that students, especially 8th graders, have a difficult time focusing on lengthy assignments.  The kids enjoy poetry because most forms we study are "short" and "easy".

As part of my unit, I like to introduce students to various poets and forms of poetry.  Sharon Creech's books, Love that Dog and Hate that Cat provide a unique way to introduce poets such as Robert Frost, William Carlos Williams and T.S. Elliot. 

The novel Love that Dog, written in the form of poems, introduce us to Jack.  Jack is a reluctant poet.  He believes only girls write poetry.  As we read his journal, we learn that Jack has a dog he loves.  As we learn more about Jack and his dog, Jack finds his voice and his inner-poet.

In the follow up novel Hate that Cat, Jack finds himself in Miss Strechberry's classroom for a second year -- she has looped with her class.  This year Jack explores metaphors, similes and onomatopoeia and the concept of silence.

Each of these books is a quick, quick read.  But, despite that fact, there is so much gained in so little time.  I cannot wait to use each of these as an introduction to William Carlos Williams, shape poetry and more!

The Mysterious Benedict Society

I love clever books.  I especially love clever books written for children.  This book begins with an advertisement in a newspaper, "Are you a gifted child looking for special opportunities?"  With this simple question we met Rynie, Sticky, Kate and Constance and The Mysterious Benedict Society begins!

I love that each of the 4 children have characteristics that will surely appeal to a reader:  Rynie, the thoughtful and clever puzzle solver; Sticky, a walking encyclopedia of both big and small facts; Kate, with her bucket ready, the MacGyver of the group; and finally, Constance, her dry wit, sarcasm and crabbiness.

The four children along with several adults are off to save the world from a terrible invention:  the Whisperer.  Along the way, they learn to recognize and appreciate each others' talents and question what is right.  Trenton Lee Stewart has created a special and wondrous world where the importance of children is celebrated.

At nearly 500 pages, The Mysterious Benedict Society is a lengthy book, but it is so enticing that I truly didn't mind and was sad the story was over!  Luckily for me, I have the sequel The Mysterious Benedict Society and the Perilous Journey waiting on my shelf!

Saturday, March 6, 2010

Middlesex

I had started this book years ago, but it was a borrowed copy from my Mom.  She wanted it back before I could finish.  In any case, I finished the book this evening.  I enjoyed Calliope/Cal's story, but felt that Eugenides spent far too much time on the back story.  I believe her story is compelling enough not to have to go back three generations.

Yes, Calliope/Cal is a hermaphrodite.  But, what could have been merely an exploitative tale of sexual discovery, was a very touching coming-of-age story.  I also enjoyed her narration throughout the novel; it was as if she were speaking to me, just telling her story. Unfortunately, she went too far back, historically, for me to love every minute of the story.

However, despite the drudgery of the past, Eugenides's ability to convey human emotion and intensely realistic characters is amazing.  I felt as though I was a part of the Stephanides family. So much so, that as the book ended I was sad to say goodbye.

The Last Days of the Romanovs: Tragedy at Ekaterinburg

I remember seeing a made for TV movie, or perhaps it was Danielle Steel's Zoya that first piqued my interest in the Romanov family.  Although I don't know too much about the dynasty, I love reading anything about royal families.   The reviews on the outside of this book touted a history book that read like a "true crime thriller".  I unfortunately, disagree.  This book, heavily researched by Helen Rappaport truly reads like a text book, until Chapter 14.  This is, however, the second to the last chapter of the book.

I hadn't realized that this book would report in great tedious detail every minute of the last days of the Romanovs and their captors.    If I were more a scholar of Russian/ Soviet history, this would be an excellent read.  I found myself skimming and scanning the pages in order to finish the book.  It wasn't until the final pages that I began to become much more interested. 

I found the aftermath of discovering the grave site and the subsequent research to prove the grave sites belong to the Romanov family a much more intriguing story.  All in all, Rappaport's book is a good one, just not the story I happened to be looking for.

Wednesday, March 3, 2010

I Can Be Anything

So, normally, I wouldn't count a picture book as one of my 100 books, but I am a HUGE Jerry Spinelli fan.  Anything written by Mr. Spinelli counts in my book!

This is a wonderful picture book, perfect for graduation (as my cover notes) with simply gorgeous illustrations by Jimmy Liao.  The book follows a little boy and his toy rabbit as he day dreams the many things he could be.  The jobs are smile inducing:  mixing bowl licker, dandelion blower, best part saver and on and on.

I say I bought this book for my daughter, but the truth be told, it's a picture book I bought just for me!

Monday, March 1, 2010

March 2010

March in Chicago always holds the promise of more snow, rain and YUCK!  March is also Intersession time!  3 weeks off from the responsibilities of being a classroom teacher.  Time to cuddle up with a few good books and write some reviews!  So, although I'll be teaching two classes during the mornings of my first week off, I'm hoping to be able to get to all of the books on my shelves that need to be read! 

My students are actually motivating me to get a lot of reading done over intersession.  I have one student who has already read more books than I have this year and another who is quickly catching up!  I plan on gaining a lot of ground over break.  But, I must say, I'm quite happy my project is inspiring the young adults I work with!


18.  Middlesex by Jeffrey Eudenides  
19.  The Last Days of the Romanovs:  Tragedy at Ekaterinberg  by Helen Rappaport  
20.  I Can Be Anything  written by Jerry Spinelli  illustrated by Jimmy Liao
21.  The Mysterious Benedict Society by Trenton Lee Stewart   
22.  Love that Dog by Sharon Creech
23.  Hate that Cat by Sharon Creech
24.  The Sunflower by Simon Wisenthal
25.  The Story of Edgar Sawtelle:  A Novel  by David Wroblewski 
26.  13 Little Blue Envelopes by Maureen Johnson
27.  Ruined:  A Novel by Paula Morris 
28.  The Book of One Hundred Truths by Julie Schumacher 
29.  Kiss My Math:  Showing Pre-Algebra Who's Boss by Danica McKellar 
30.  The Mysterious Benedict Society and the Perilous Journey by Trenton Lee Stewart 
31.  The House on Mango Street by Sandra Cisneros 
32.  Out of My Mind by Sharon M. Draper 
33.  Finally by Wendy Mass  
34.  Shooting the Moon by Frances O'Roark Dowell 
35.  Snow Flower and the Secret Fan by Lisa See 
36.  March Toward the Thunder by Joseph Bruchac 
37.  Getting Stoned with Savages:  A Trip Through the Islands of Fiji and Vanuatu by J. Maarten Troost
38.  Anne Frank:  The Book, The Life, The Afterlife  by Francine Prose 
39.  Fallen Angels by Walter Dean Myers 
40.  Heavy Words Lightly Thrown:  The Reason Behind the Rhyme by Chris Roberts 
41.  Briar Rose by Jane Yolen 
42.  A River of Words:  The Story of William Carlos Williams written by Jen Bryant illustrated by Melissa Sweet
43.  Stuck in Neutral by Terry Trueman 
44.  Sunrise over Fallujah by Walter Dean Myer 
45.  The Postmistress by Sarah Blake